The blame game: shifting perceptions on truck and passenger vehicle collisions

Posted 27 Jan 2025

Commercial vehicle drivers and fleet operators play a vital role in sustaining our global economy. These vehicles deliver the materials that build our infrastructure and the goods that sustain our everyday lives.

Despite their critical importance, commercial drivers often face unfair blame in road accidents, as well as being frequent targets for insurance claims. This not only impacts businesses financially but also presents challenges to their reputation and morale. 

However, research consistently reveals a surprising truth: in many collisions involving commercial vehicles, the fault often lies elsewhere. It’s time to rethink how we approach road safety and accountability. 

The reality behind commercial vehicle accidents 

When accidents involving large trucks occur, public perception often defaults to blaming the truck driver—perhaps it’s a case of “blame the big guy.” Yet, recent studies by the US Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) tell a different story.

According to the latest data, a significant portion of collisions involving large trucks are caused by passenger vehicle drivers. In fact, the FMCSA’s 2021 report indicates that passenger vehicle drivers are responsible for 68-74% of crashes involving large trucks. This highlights the ongoing importance of safe driving practices for all road users. 

Despite these findings, commercial businesses are often held accountable. They face mounting insurance claims, reputational damage, and serious disruptions to their operations. This underscores the importance of taking proactive steps—not just for financial reasons but to enhance safety and exonerate their drivers of any wrongdoing. 

Why passenger vehicles are often at fault 

Many accidents involving trucks stem from the actions of passenger vehicle drivers, who may not fully understand the unique challenges of operating large vehicles. Common mistakes include: 

  • Cutting off trucks: Misjudging stopping distances and manoeuvrability leads to risky lane changes. 
  • Driving in blind spots: Trucks have extensive blind spots that passenger drivers often overlook, creating risks for everyone on the road. 
  • Speeding and reckless driving: Tailgating, weaving through traffic, or aggressive behaviours are especially hazardous around large vehicles. 
  • Distracted driving: The rise of mobile phone use contributes significantly to collisions, as drivers focus on their devices instead of the road. 

By examining the behaviours of passenger vehicle drivers, it becomes clear that awareness, education, and technology are essential for reducing these incidents. 

Understanding the challenges commercial drivers face 

Operating a large truck isn’t easy, and the challenges drivers face are significant. By understanding these hurdles, we can promote safer road-sharing practices: 

  • Stopping distance: Trucks require much more space to come to a complete stop compared to passenger vehicles. 
  • Limited visibility: Large trucks have substantial blind spots along the sides, rear, and even the front, where smaller vehicles may go unnoticed. 
  • Complex manoeuvring: Sharp turns and lane changes are more challenging and demand extra caution. 

Despite these challenges, commercial drivers consistently demonstrate professionalism and a commitment to safety. They undergo specialised training in defensive driving and hazard avoidance and adhere to strict regulatory standards, such as hours-of-service limits designed to ensure they remain alert during long shifts. Still, businesses must do everything possible to support them and ensure a safe working environment. 

Why businesses need to act 

Although passenger vehicle drivers are often at fault, the reality is that commercial businesses bear the burden of blame. This makes it essential for fleets to take proactive steps to reduce accidents, protect drivers, and mitigate risks. By doing so, businesses can gather clear evidence to demonstrate when their drivers are not at fault, and even when they are.  

This approach not only delivers significant savings on insurance claims but also minimises operational disruptions and ensures the right party is held accountable. Beyond the financial benefits, it’s about creating a culture of accountability and prioritising safety for everyone on the roads. 

How can CameraMatics help?

At CameraMatics, our mission is to enhance road safety for all—drivers, businesses, and the public. For commercial drivers, our technology not only protects against fraudulent claims but also helps exonerate them in situations where they’ve been wrongly blamed. However, our main priority isn’t about assigning fault after an accident; it’s about preventing accidents from occurring in the first place. 

By equipping fleets with advanced telematics, camera systems, y AI-powered technology, CameraMatics helps fleet operators and drivers take control of their safety. Our solutions: 

  • Telematics & Camera Systems: CameraMatics integrates advanced telematics and camera systems that provide real-time insights into the behaviour of both the vehicle and the driver. For instance, the system can monitor speed, harsh braking, lane departures, and other unsafe driving behaviours. It automatically records video footage when a risky event occurs, offering clear, unbiased evidence to refute false claims. 
  • AI-Powered Alerts: The AI component analyses patterns and provides predictive alerts for potential risks. For example, if a truck is approaching a high-risk area or if the driver is exhibiting signs of fatigue or distracted behaviour, the system will notify both the driver and fleet managers. This allows for immediate corrective action, significantly reducing the likelihood of an accident. 
  • Exoneration in Case of False Claims: In the unfortunate event of a collision, CameraMatics’ video evidence, along with the telematics data, can be crucial in exonerating the truck driver when they are wrongfully blamed. The footage and data can prove whether the truck was at fault, or if the passenger vehicle was responsible—especially in cases where the truck driver’s actions were misinterpreted or misconstrued. 

This approach not only safeguards your business and drivers but also supports Vision Zero—a global initiative aiming for zero fatalities and serious injuries by 2050. 

Take proactive steps for safety 

At the end of the day, fleet safety goes beyond protecting your bottom line—it’s about protecting lives and ensuring every road user gets home safely. By embracing advanced technology and promoting accountability, your business can make a real difference in creating safer roads for everyone. 

Take the first step –  get in touch with CameraMatics today 

Protect your drivers, fleet and business
es_ESSpanish